Who has the best-reasoned estimates of time periods for energy returned on energy invested for solar?

Who has the best-reasoned estimates of time periods for energy returned on energy invested for solar?

I have been looking at the scientific literature on solar- how much energy does it take to make and install a panel, how much energy does the panel return over its lifetime, what is the energy payback period. (Along the way I got sidetracked into the time factor - how often does the energy get paid back.)

My initial thoughts were very optimistic. I got excited by an article at:

https://cleantechnica.com/2018/02/03/solar-power-can-pay-easily/

That first link makes a very big claim - namely that solar pays back power with a very good "energy payback period."

Edit: a condensed version of the same optimistic story is at:

https://cleantechnica.com/2018/03/25/solar-power-energy-payback-time-now-super-short/

I looked at claims from NREL such as:

https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy04osti/35489.pdf

and (because a lot of science papers cited this as a source) I looked at claims from Europe such as:

http://www.ecn.nl/docs/library/report/2007/e07026-LCIdata-cSiPV-pubv2_0.xls

And as far I could tell, a solar panel is pure win. It take a few years to pay back the energy required to make it, and then it is pure energy "profit" until the end of its service life. But then doubt set in. A lot of science papers are based on the XLS spreadsheet linked above, and that spreadsheet claims that it is full of guesswork and estimates and trust in the manufacturers. Obviously, solar panel manufacturers might exaggerate their efficiency, and those exaggerations might get worked into the spreadsheet, and thence to the scientific literature. Furthermore, estimates of solar installations might fail to recognize relevant expenses of embodied energy. Maybe solar requires a lot of steel, aluminum, concrete, gravel, and water, but maybe the estimates for solar energy payback don't factor those in properly. Therefore my question is - who has the best reasoning? Whose estimates are the most comprehensive? Whose model fits the reality most accurately?

I would really love to see a retrospective study on solar panel installation, where someone put in a big solar installation and tracked all the inputs, outputs, waste factors, and unexpected outages. However, I have not yet found anything like that. I have found pro-solar folks who are busy installing panels (who don't have numbers on their "energy payback period"), and I have found anti-solar folks who claim that it is all a bunch hippie malarkey (and who refuse to believe any hopeful claims about "energy payback period"), but I have not found anyone who says, "Solar is not perfect, it has some inefficiencies, it has some unexpected flaws, and here are the numbers that measure our experience." I don't know if the scientific literature is the best place to look for such information. Helpful comments would be appreciated. Thank you.

submitted by /u/postgygaxian
[visit reddit] [comments] https://ift.tt/2GaXbGc

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Solar Jobs Resources January 24, 2018 - HELP WANTED / TRAINING AVAILABLE: Must have sunny disposition

Solar Jobs Resources January 24, 2018 - HELP WANTED / TRAINING AVAILABLE: Must have sunny disposition Welcome to the /r/solar job resource post Any and all solar job finding related questions are welcome in this recurring feature post. There are no "stupid" questions. Please help make this post a great resource for the community by offering suggestions for job/help listing sites as well as suggesting links to resources related to solar job training NOTE: We want to keep the reddit overlords happy so make sure you do not add any info to your comment which is specific to you such as the exact location for where you live/work, your email addresses, phone numbers, facebook page, etc. Instead, suggest that folks PM you for more info. Solar Job Sites The following are a small sampling to get this list started. To suggest an addition, add a comment below and include a link. For a site to be considered, it must have listings for multiple solar related jobs on a continual basis. ...
Read more

Solar Supports

Solar Supports I'm looking at installing a solar system at our off grid cabin this spring and I'm trying to come up with a good way to get the panels up high enough to catch decent sunlight. The roof of the cabin is not an option as there are some trees blocking it but I do have a shed that I figure I'd be able to brace the supports to, I can't use the shed roof either as it's facing the wrong direction. A couple neighbors have systems which they've put on poles that go up sort of like a street lamp or flagpole style support which is an option but I thought maybe either a frame like a scaffold kind of thing secured to the back of the shed might be a more sturdy option. What have you guys used to elevate your panels on a standalone frame, or have you seen any companies that sell good kits? I'm in BC in Canada as well. Thanks for reading. submitted by /u/dykehoncho [visit reddit] [comments] https://ift.tt/2C1elG6
Read more

PG&E Aggregate Net Metering Application Help

PG&E Aggregate Net Metering Application Help Earlier this year I completed a ground mount at a ranch in Paso Robles, CA. This ranch has two meters, requiring me to complete the PG&E’s Aggregate Net Metering Agreement. 8 months later my application has been rejected multiple times. I’ve spent dozens of hours on the phone with various support services with no solution. I’ve given it my all. Does anyone have any contacts for professionals who I can hire to complete this process for me? Or any tips for completing this process? Honestly, this issue has become the bane of my existence and I need it solved. Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you very much submitted by /u/WorldRambler [visit reddit] [comments] https://ift.tt/2NmgN1O
Read more